Archive for September, 2008

Now what do we do!? Follow up to Silent Racism message

First off, thank you to everyone for your gracious and constructive feedback from last weekend.  Racism is a tough topic for a community, and I appreciate how serious everyone took it.  The comments and corrections were all given and received with respect and appreciation. 

Most of the comments had to do with “balance”.  That is, everyone appreciated and agreed in the big picture with what I preached on; and had some practical comments.  One woman shared about being Korean and growing up in Japan where the racism is more pervasive and socially acceptable.  It’s not just a “white” thing. One man talked about how things are where he grew up in Africa, and how reconciliation is so complex because it also involves so much more than race (he used gender as an example).  Another woman questioned (rightly) my use of the word mutulation to describe people who have plastic surgery to look more caucasian.  While agreeing that the thinking and the imagery which spawned the need for surgery is wrong she pushed back concerned that my comment was condemning of hurting people, and encouraged me to not hurt the hurting.  There were several more things shared but I think this is pretty representative. 

By the way, if you are someone who has had plastic surgery please know that I never intended to smere an entire field of medicine that performs and amazingly great amount of things.  My comment was an attempt to reveal the insidious depth and toxic effects that this particular sin can wreak on the human soul.  If you have had surgery or skin lighteners, please know that I don’t condemn you.  I would love to talk with you, ask your forgiveness if it hurt you, and seek the Lord’s heart together for healing and restoration. 

On the “thank you” side I received grateful comments and hugs from people who felt like their struggles and hurts finally got a fair airing.  It was important to encourage the majority to be good hosts and to share the burden of reconciliation as a community so that it’s not the responsibility of a few who are already hurt and wounded by racism. So all-in-all I think it was a fair start.  But it’s not all that needs to occur. 

To “do” what the Lord is asking us to “be” will require that this issue never go away.  It’s not a checklist item, but a perception and a sensitivity that we are just beginning to acquire (but don’t yet have).  If we are to be a healthy, honoring place of “all people” then we have to continue walking and working.  We have some “structural” things to deal with.  We need more and deeper venues for exploring this vitally important topic.  We need perseverence and consistency in our thinking and intention. 

The elders are talking about this.  Some great suggestions have been made about “next steps,” but I wanted to explicitly ask for your insight and opinion on “next steps.” 

What ideas do you have to keep this issue fresh?  To provide opportunities for people to really explore their souls, deal with their own fears and racism?  To listen to racism’s effects on the people the Lord has brought here to be loved and to love – to be part of their healing and ours?  Not just for “us”, but for those who will be “us” in the future?  Any ideas for our kids? 

I would love hear any and all ideas and opinions. 

I would offer one final encouragement today.  This is hard.  It makes relationships and motivations for friendship feel awkward, maybe even forced.  This always happens when we confront deep seated things that often go unchallenged (please don’t forget what was shared about passive racism-read the previous post if you have).  We are doing this not to be popular or PC or merely provocative.  We are doing this because we are following our Lord, and he requires it of us.  He is making us, our community, more Kingdom-like.  THIS IS AWESOME!  It’s hard and difficult, but it is the type of hard work and difficult that can change the world.  Don’t loose sight of this in the awkwardness.  God is changing everything, and he is letting us be part of his transformation. 

Hallelujah! 

Amen.

Leave a Comment

Silent Racism

I think it’s important that we start to get back into our conversation on race and racism.  I particularly want to bring up the issue of “silent racism.”  My understanding of this comes from Barbara Trepagnier’s book Silent Racism, How Well-Meaning White People Perpetuate the Racial Divide (Paradigm Publishers, 2006). 

 

Silent racism is the racism that exists in those who claim to not be racist.  It is a form of racism that comes from language that distorts racial reality regardless of whether the distorted language is defensive and self-serving; or whether it is well-meaning, naïve, or utopian.  It is grounded in the notion that racism exists only in the extreme (called oppositional categories).  That is, that racism is ONLY active hate and opposition (in either statements or actions).   If you are not that, if you want equality and equal opportunity, if you don’t want to judge by the color of skin; then you are not racist.  This kind of thinking masks the more subtle forms of racism that are perpetuated in both society and the human heart. 

 

Trapagnier writes, “Silent racism is not the same as prejudice, which is generally perceived as bigoted attitudes held by individual whites about a minority group.  Silent racism, on the contrary, is not limited to intolerant whites – it inhabits the minds of all white people whether or not they acknowledge it or are aware of it.  Silent racism is more closely linked to the ‘images, attitudes, fictions, and notions that link to and buttress systemic racism [and] constitute a broad white-racist worldview’ (Feagin 2001: 34).”   

 

Trapagnier discusses two forms of silent racism:  stereotypical images and paternalistic assumptions.  Stereotypical images are the result of misinformation about minorities prevalent in the culture, while paternalistic assumptions result from a sense of superiority on the side of whites in comparison to minority cultures, languages, customs, history, etc.  Silent racism includes passivity about race issues in the form of “detachment from race matters, apprehension about being perceived as racist, and confusion about what is racist and what is not racist.”  (Trapagnier 2006, 6) 

 

So let’s examine ourselves in light of this. 

Do I think of racism only in the extremes of all or nothing? 

 

What do you think about the idea that there is in the minds of all whites “images, attitudes, fictions, and notions” which discount people and their achievement? 

 

Do you see examples of stereotypical images or paternalistic assumptions in your own view of Asians, Nigerians, Sudanese, Latinos, and immigrants? 

 

What about the passive types of silent racism?  Are you detached from the topic?  Are you apprehensive or fearful of being perceived as racist?  Confused or daunted by the complexity and seriousness of it so that you just keep your head down and hope you don’t have to deal with it? 

 

These questions are important.  I hope you don’t just read them and move on.  My prayer is that you will allow them to open up your heart and mind.  This issue of silent racism is so significant to our calling as a multiethnic, multiracial church.  The white majority of our congregation has to let its blindness and ignorance of race matters be challenged, confronted, and healed if a genuine and truly loving community is to be formed.

 

The non-white members of the congregation need to understand that part of their gift is to be the Lord’s instruments in healing and overcoming the “favoritism” (James 2) and unchallenged pride that hinders the work of God, who is making a people for himself from every tribe and nation and language.  The Lord is not a White God who is making all people White.  He is the Lord who made all people in their diversity and who is calling them (us) in their diversity to be reconciled to Him and one another through Christ’s gift of grace and mercy.  Silent racism is a pride-based, deep-seated sin which resists the revealed will of God.  It must be squarely faced and addressed. 

 

But let’s keep this in perspective.  This doesn’t have to be contentious or demeaning.  The goal of repentance is not feeling badly about ourselves.  The goal of repentance is getting over ourselves and the ways we compromise the Lord’s goodness and getting back on track in love and peace.   If we can get past the extremes of racism=active hate, then we can get past the self-serving lie which says I am without sin in this issue.  If I am an example of silent racism (which I am) then I can confidently assert as a general principle that silent racism exists at OTC.  Therefore, it is good for all of us to examine our hearts, learn, repent, and mature because as it exists in my heart and mind it is an affront to God.

 

As in all things, don’t have the conversation alone in your own head.  We are a community.  We are part of one another for things like this – for the hard things as well as the fun and the joyous.  In matters of the heart we are most in need of others to help overcome our own blind spots about ourselves. 

Comments (1)